Discord shows server icons and avatars small most of the time, in the server list and next to chat messages. It would be reasonable to assume a small source image is good enough for a small display, but the same icon also appears larger in places such as server settings, invites and profile views. Discord's minimum icon size is 128x128 pixels, and it suggests cropping in multiples of 128 (256, 384 and so on). It doesn't publish a recommended size, so 512x512 is a practical starting point: a multiple of 128 with enough detail for the larger views, while a 128x128 upload can look soft once it's shown any bigger.
The circle crop is the part people miss most often. Every server icon and avatar gets masked into a circle regardless of what shape the source image is. If you design a square logo with text or details reaching into the corners, that content sits outside the circular mask and simply never displays. The safe approach is to treat the circle inscribed inside your square canvas as the actual visible area, and keep everything important, especially text, within that inner circle. Turn on the circle guide in the preview, or choose Fit to shrink the whole logo inside the frame with transparent padding.
Server banners have two different accepted sizes for a reason
Discord recommends 960x540 pixels at a 16:9 ratio for a server banner, and says a 1920x1080 image is resized automatically if you upload one. Either works; 960x540 is what Discord asks for and gives a smaller file. The separate server invite background is different: Discord requires exactly 1920x1080 in JPG or PNG, and the invite pop-up covers the middle of it. For the banner itself, Discord suggests keeping the top 48 pixels simple so the server name stays readable, avoiding logos or text, and using key art or subtle background art instead. Server banners need Boost Level 2, and animated banners need Level 3.
The profile banner has a blind spot the server banner doesn't
A personal profile banner, the Nitro-only feature, needs at least 680x240 pixels according to Discord's Custom Profiles article (its older Per-Server Profiles article still says 600x240), as a PNG, JPG or animated GIF under 10 MB. It has a constraint that server banners don't share: your circular avatar overlaps its lower-left part. A banner design that places its focal point in that corner competes with the avatar sitting on top of it. Shifting the visual weight toward the centre or right half of the frame avoids that overlap. Discord also lets you crop the banner after upload, so a little extra margin around the subject helps.